Wellyopolis

May 03, 2005

Ignorance in the Star Tribune

You don't have to be an immigrant to be here legally ...

The Star Tribune (and many other papers) reports that: "the 11 states that issue driver's licenses to noncitizens are Maryland, Michigan, Montana, New Mexico, North Carolina, Hawaii, Oregon, Tennessee, Utah, Washington and Wisconsin."

Let me explain this slowly. You do not have to be a citizen or immigrant to be in the United States legally and wish to obtain a drivers license. There are about 600,000 foreign students in the United States who are not immigrants, but may want to obtain a drivers license. As well as students there are other exchange visitors (au pairs, scholars, journalists) and representatives of foreign institutions or governments who may reside in America without intending to live here.

Perhaps it's not clear to the Star Tribune, nor to Congress, but a driver's license is a document that proves people have met some minimum (and in Minnesota they really are minimum) standards of competence to drive on public roads.

An identification card is a card that proves you are who you say you are.

Those are two quite different things. They ought not to be conflated.

Posted by robe0419 at May 3, 2005 12:33 PM | TrackBack
Comments

Periodically, a certain enthusiasm rises for universal national ID cards for a variety of reasons. Libertarian groups usually do their best to see that such ideas never get off the ground. Yet, the vast majority of adults carry a de facto ID called a driver's license.

I don't carry a picture ID aside from my U card and my DL. There are many instances when I might be asked to show my DL when I'm not driving. I'm not sure if it's the law of the land or local ordinance, but I think any adult in public is obligated to carry some form of government issued ID when in public (I could be wrong on that, but it seems the SCOTUS not long ago held that we don't have the right to withhold our identities from police if they ask). The DL, intentionally or not, has become that ID. I agree, however, that that shouldn't necessarily be the case.

Posted by: Jim at May 3, 2005 01:39 PM
The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author. The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.